Tuesday, January 27, 2009

Congressman Cleaver to respond with the usual form letter (things for any concerned citizen to consider)

(the following is an e-mail sent to Congressman Cleaver after the telephone town hall on 1/27 regarding the new "Stimulus" package.)

Thank you for the telephone town hall.

My concern, as always, with a bill like this, concerning loans and the banking sector, is that the problems created by the inherent natures of the services of the banking industry.

In Obama's Inauguration speech, he mentioned foreign leadership being judged by what they create, not what they destroy. I would hope that we can apply this litmus test here at home.

What the banking sector does create is Debt and Inflation. Both are very destructive. While I appreciate the need for the services a banking industry provide, and the need for investment, especially in a financially unstable time, I fear what can happen when Fractional Reserve Banking is not placed in check, but instead is encouraged through these government spending programs that essentially feed money to the banks that caused this issue.

We blame the subprime mortgage industry and the debt securitization being packaged into these bundles for the problem. But the banks can only profit when new lending is had. My fear is that the offered solutions to this problem will cause any government and taxpayer funds to wind up in the hands of the banking sector and a new bubble will be created through the encouragement of new lending.

That money, when created, will cause inflation, then filtered through the Fractional Reserve Banking time and time again, using this money to create more...and more inflation arrives....

All the while leaving taxpayers with the bill with one edge of the sword, and the borrower with the bill with the other edge.

I see the businesses, taxpayers, and other borrowers who pay their loans and taxes faithfully having to pay for these government packages multiple times over. First through paying back their loans, then through taxes, then through interest on the debts both public and private, then through interest on the exponential creation of dollars through the banking sector.

I hardly see how borrowing more money to create more investment opportunities (debt opportunities) could outweigh these negatives.

Please, Congressman, I urge you to take an aggressive stance on the Inflation and Debt problems that become the roots of these bubbles.

I say the roots, because we only need to ask ourselves how someone could encapture theirself insubprime loans with the inability to pay....My argument would be the rise in living costs.

We're often given GDP and the Consumer Price Index as economic indicators. The consumer Price Index is a joke, when determining living expenses of the country because it doesn't address the basic fundamental costs of living.

First, loans (interest rates) are excluded from the CPI, so one's own housing, transportation, and educational costs are not accurately configured.

Secondly, Government Subsidized Programs (taxes) are excluded from the CPI, so public transportation, food, utilities and other tax-subidized programs aren't accurately figured in as costs to the taxpayer in the CPI

Third, and this is the most important, our trade deficit. When a job goes overseas, the cost goes down, yet, the person performing that job, has a chance, to find other employment. Usually as our manufacturing sector whittles away, that next job winds up in the service sector.

While services have value, wealth is determined in tangible assets. When we do not create these tangible assets here at home, the real wealth goes out of the country. So while the price of a particular good may go down when manufactured overseas, the CPI fails to address the fact that there are other built in costs to money leaving the country.

This is why the United States borrows so much foreign debt. This is money we have willingly seized to foreign manufacturing through our trade deficit. Foreign nations profit off of our consumerism, then loan that money back to us.

Please ponder this one question before you respond....What happens when an entire country defaults on its loans?

2 comments:

Marcus said...

Have you gotten a response yet?

Mild said...

Dear Kevin:



Thank you for contacting me regarding H.R. 1, the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009, also known as the 2009 stimulus plan. I appreciate hearing from you on this important issue.



As you already know, H.R. 1 will direct $550 billion to a variety of programs, including carefully targeted priority investments and provisions designed to allow the public to track the spending. The plan's goal is to jumpstart economic growth through job creation and investment in national infrastructure.



The legislation will make important improvements to our nation's roads, bridges, transit, and waterways with $30 billion for federal highway construction. $31 billion is directed towards modernization of federal and other public infrastructure with investments that lead to long-term energy cost savings. Also $19 billion will fund clean water, flood control, and environmental restoration investments, and $10 billion will be invested in mass transit and rail projects. All funding in the measure will support programs and projects that would be ready to start within ninety days of signing of the bill.



Education will receive substantial support in the legislation as well, since more Americans enroll in school when the economy is suffering. The measure includes $41 billion for local school districts, and $79 billion in state fiscal relief to prevent cutbacks to key services, including $39 billion to local school districts and public colleges and universities. The legislation also includes $15.6 billion to increase the Pell Grant by $500.



To save money and lives, the measure will update and computerize our healthcare system to cut red tape, prevent medical mistakes, and help reduce healthcare by billions of dollars annually. The legislation will fund our nation's over-extended healthcare system, with $20 billion going to health information technology and $4.1 billion for preventive care and evaluation of the most effective treatments. $39 billion will support those who lose their jobs by helping them to pay the cost of keeping their employers provided healthcare under COBRA, with a 65% subsidy for 12 months.



Unemployment has risen sharply to 7.2% nationally, and to 7.3% in Missouri. This measure will address these troubling numbers, with $43 billion for increased unemployment benefits and job training. Additionally, $20 billion will help to increase the food stamp benefit by over 13% in order to help balance rising food costs.



In addition, the measure will include energy provisions to aid in reaching national energy independence. $32 billion will support transformation of energy transmission, distribution, and production systems by allowing for a smarter and better grid and focusing investment in renewable technology. $16 billion will make energy efficient retrofits and repair public housing, and weatherization of modest-income homes is funded at $6 billion in the legislation as well.



In addition to funding various programs to stimulate the economy, the measure will include provisions to ensure accountability of the spending. The legislation will create a new presidential website to detail the names of program managers, how funds are spent, and to publish all announcements of contract and grant competitions and awards. The measure will include a public notification of funding that will include a description of the investment, the purpose, the total cost and why the activity should be funded with recovery dollars. Under the legislation, governors, mayors, or those making funding decisions must personally certify that the investment has been fully vetted and is an appropriate use of taxpayer dollars. A Recovery Act Accountability and Transparency Board will be created to review management of recovery dollars and provide early warning of problems. Additionally, the provision bans the inclusion of earmarks.



The House approved H.R. 1 on January 28, 2009 by a vote of 244-188, with my support. The measure is now being considered by the Senate. I am confident this measure will encourage economic growth and make needed investments to needed sectors of infrastructure, in order to improve the movement of commerce.



Again, thank you for sharing your views with me. Please do not hesitate to contact me in the future if I may be of further assistance. Also, I encourage you to visit my website at http://www.house.gov/cleaver, where you can sign up for my electronic newsletter and receive updates on my latest activities as your Representative.



Sincerely

Emanuel Cleaver, II

Member of Congress